Guide
Compare business entities
Six ways to structure a business, what each one does about liability and tax, and who each suits. The short version: if you want personal asset protection without much administration, an LLC is usually the answer, and everything else is a reason to deviate from that.
The options side by side
Personal liability means whether your own assets are exposed to business debts. Tax treatment is the federal default; several of these can elect something different.
| Structure | Personal liability | Taxed as | State filing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sole proprietorship | Fully exposed | Owner’s personal return | None |
| General partnership | Fully exposed | Passes through to partners | None in most states |
| LLC | Protected | Owner or partnership by default | Articles of organization |
| C corporation | Protected | Corporation pays its own tax | Articles of incorporation |
| S corporation | Protected | Passes through to shareholders | An IRS election on an LLC or corporation |
| Non-profit corporation | Protected | Taxable until the IRS grants exemption | Articles of incorporation |
Sole proprietorship
The default. If you start selling and register nothing, this is what you are. There is no filing and no separation: the business and you are the same legal person, so business debts are your debts and a claim against the business reaches your savings and your house. It is free and simple, and that is the whole case for it. You may still need a local license, a sales tax permit, and a DBA if you trade under a name that is not your own.
General partnership
Two or more people in business together without forming anything. Like a sole proprietorship, it exists by default and offers no liability protection, with the added problem that each partner can usually bind the others and is exposed to what they do. Profit passes through to the partners’ personal returns. If you are going into business with someone, this is the structure to move away from rather than into.
Limited liability company
The common choice for small businesses, because it gives the liability protection of a corporation without the board, the shares or the meetings. Owners are members, ownership is recorded in an operating agreement rather than share certificates, and by default the IRS taxes a single owner like a sole proprietor and a multi owner LLC like a partnership. An LLC can elect S or C corporation taxation later without changing its legal form, which is what makes it flexible.
C corporation
A corporation is what you form when you want shares. It suits companies raising outside investment, planning to grant equity to employees, or expecting to be acquired, because investors understand stock and the structure supports it. The cost is formality and tax: a board, officers, bylaws, minutes and annual meetings, and the corporation pays tax on its profit before shareholders pay again on dividends.
S corporation
Not a separate kind of company. It is a tax election an eligible LLC or corporation makes with the IRS, so profit passes through to the owners rather than being taxed at the company first. It can reduce self employment tax once profit is high enough to support paying the owner a reasonable salary. The limits are strict: no more than 100 shareholders, one class of stock, and owners must be US citizens or resident aliens.
Non-profit corporation
Formed with a state like any other corporation, but nobody owns it and surplus cannot be distributed. Forming it does not make it tax exempt: that is a separate application to the IRS, usually Form 1023 or 1023-EZ, and until the IRS grants exemption the organization is a taxable corporation and donations are not deductible.
LLC or S corporation? The question people actually mean
These are not alternatives, which is why the comparison feels slippery. An LLC is an entity you form with a state. An S corporation is a way of taxing one. The real question is whether your LLC should make the election, and the answer is mostly arithmetic: below the point where the business could pay you a reasonable salary and still have profit left over, the payroll and accounting the election requires usually costs more than the self employment tax it saves. Above it, the election starts to pay. Your accountant can put numbers on that in a way a web page cannot.
S corporation or C corporation?
Same legal structure, different tax treatment. A C corporation pays tax on its own profit and shareholders pay again on dividends. An S corporation passes profit through to shareholders, avoiding that second layer, but accepts limits a C corporation does not have: the shareholder cap, the single class of stock, and the restriction on who can own shares. Those limits are exactly why companies raising venture capital stay C corporations, since investment funds and foreign investors cannot hold S corporation stock.
DBA or a company?
A DBA, also called a fictitious or assumed name, is not a business structure at all. It registers the fact that you trade under a name other than your legal one. It gives no liability protection, no tax change and no separate legal existence. A sole proprietor with a DBA is still a sole proprietor, personally liable for everything. If the reason you are looking at a DBA is that you want a business name, an LLC gives you the name and the protection together.
How to decide
Ask three questions in order. Is there anything you would lose if the business were sued or could not pay a debt? If yes, rule out sole proprietorship and general partnership. Do you need to issue stock to investors or employees? If yes, incorporate; if no, an LLC is simpler and does the same protective job. Is profit high enough that payroll would save you tax? If yes, ask your accountant about the S election, which you can make on either.
Questions people ask
Which structure is best for a small business?
For most, an LLC. It protects personal assets, costs little to maintain, and can change its tax treatment later without changing its legal form. Incorporate instead if you need shares for investors or employees.
Can I change structure later?
Yes, with varying difficulty. Electing S or C corporation taxation on an LLC is straightforward and does not change the legal entity. Converting an LLC into a corporation outright is possible in most states but is a filing with tax consequences, so take advice first.
Does an LLC or corporation protect me completely?
No. It separates your personal assets from the company’s debts. It does not cover your own negligence, it does not survive treating the company as a personal account, and it does nothing about a personal guarantee, which is what most lenders ask a new company’s owner to sign.
Is a non-profit automatically tax exempt?
No. Forming a non-profit corporation with a state creates the entity. Tax exemption is a separate IRS application, and until it is granted the organization is taxed as a corporation and donations are not deductible.
Which entities can you form for me?
LLCs, corporations, S corporations and non-profit corporations, in every state. Sole proprietorships and general partnerships are not formed with a state, so there is nothing to file for those.
Decided which one you need?
Choose your entity type and state, and we will show the full price including that state’s own filing fee before you pay anything.